The Supply Chain
At the close of his briefing at the Farnborough air show, 787 VP and General Manager Pat Shanahan was asked about a second final assembly line and if it could soften the impact of follow-on delivery delays to customers.
"Well, I don't think a second [final assembly line] would solve the issue with four [assembly] positions... it's just a matter of work," said Shanahan.
Following up, the reporter asked, "You're not going to open a second final assembly line?"
"Not yet, I'm not producing very many airplanes yet so it would sit idle," replied Shanahan.
The green light for a second assembly line can wait, but the existing supply chain first has to be prepared to meet the demands of today.
For the long-term success of the program, supply chain fortification is essential for ramping up production.
Spirit Aerosystems, which has demonstrated itself to be the most capable systems integrator of the program's six primary structural suppliers, is settling in for the production rate increase this October.
The Wichita based-company delivered the nose section for Dreamliner Four 100% complete.
Complete 787 block point re-engineering plans were delivered to Spirit last week according to a Wichita based 787 program staffer familiar with the changes.
"Along with the supply-chain design changes there have been many minor engineering improvements, mostly for weight reduction purposes," says the staffer. "Now that we have our final "this is the way we want it built, soup to nuts," things should go quite a bit smoother."
Neither Spirit nor Boeing could specifically discuss the engineering plan for weight reduction on early production aircraft, though each company emphasized the they are in continual discussion about how to take weight out of the airplane and improvements are constantly being built into the aircraft's design.
Structural components manufactured by Alenia have improved markedly in recent months, according to sources in Charleston and Everett. Section 44, the bonnet structure in the center fuselage barrel, was delivered to Charleston shop complete for Dreamliner Seven in June, making Alenia the first partner to deliver completed sections. In addition, the horizontal stabilizer for Dreamliner Five arrived in Everett six weeks ago and virtually complete.
"Well, I don't think a second [final assembly line] would solve the issue with four [assembly] positions... it's just a matter of work," said Shanahan.
Following up, the reporter asked, "You're not going to open a second final assembly line?"
"Not yet, I'm not producing very many airplanes yet so it would sit idle," replied Shanahan.
The green light for a second assembly line can wait, but the existing supply chain first has to be prepared to meet the demands of today.
For the long-term success of the program, supply chain fortification is essential for ramping up production.
Spirit Aerosystems, which has demonstrated itself to be the most capable systems integrator of the program's six primary structural suppliers, is settling in for the production rate increase this October.
The Wichita based-company delivered the nose section for Dreamliner Four 100% complete.
Complete 787 block point re-engineering plans were delivered to Spirit last week according to a Wichita based 787 program staffer familiar with the changes.
"Along with the supply-chain design changes there have been many minor engineering improvements, mostly for weight reduction purposes," says the staffer. "Now that we have our final "this is the way we want it built, soup to nuts," things should go quite a bit smoother."
Neither Spirit nor Boeing could specifically discuss the engineering plan for weight reduction on early production aircraft, though each company emphasized the they are in continual discussion about how to take weight out of the airplane and improvements are constantly being built into the aircraft's design.
Structural components manufactured by Alenia have improved markedly in recent months, according to sources in Charleston and Everett. Section 44, the bonnet structure in the center fuselage barrel, was delivered to Charleston shop complete for Dreamliner Seven in June, making Alenia the first partner to deliver completed sections. In addition, the horizontal stabilizer for Dreamliner Five arrived in Everett six weeks ago and virtually complete.
Boeing continues to increase the number of manufacturing and quality engineers at the North Charleston factory, though even with the expertise held by the newly arrived staff, the learning curve exists for both Boeing and native Charleston staff as well.
"When you're building the first few units, manufacturing planning is the first place that captures a tremendous amount of learning," says Shanahan. "That's where you reconcile all the engineering and the parts and the tooling and the detailed steps of the process and believe it or not, the final end state of those manufacturing plans is a lot more mature after two or three units than on number one.
Shanahan adds that for the mechanic working directly with the aircraft, the long cycle length, 20 to 30 days, the time between starting and finishing work on a shipset, experience is the key driver in overcoming the learning curve.
Shanahan believes that the employees, "at Global Aeronautica have a much better chance of doing their job if all they have to do is contend with is doing their work, that allows them to do things more in sequence."
With shop complete structures coming to Charleston, the question becomes how quickly Global Aeronautica is able to integrate the systems and deliver them to final assembly. Dreamliner Four had the longest integration time of any center fuselage at almost eleven months; though it was the most complete to date. To meet the demands of the production ramp up, Global Aeronautica must reduce shipset integration time to keep pace with other structural suppliers.
"At Global, it's been more process we've had to supplement, pick your problem," says Shanahan. "Traveled work, part shortages, management that doesn't have the depth of experience in aerospace and obviously new workers...it's an interesting mix of skills to be outside of Everett, Washington."
Staff hired directly by Global Aeronautica are responsible solely for the structural join of the center fuselage. Following the join, contractors from Boeing, Alenia and the Kawasaki and Fuji Heavy Industries take over to integrate the barrels with systems, wiring, ducting and insulation.
By mid-month Global Aeronautica is expected to receive structural sections for Dreamliner Eight, the second production 787, and the 10th to come through Charleson. To date, Global Aeronautica has accommodated up to four shipsets at a time. The Charleston facility has a maximum capacity of up to 10 shipsets, five on each existing line.
Another veteran engineer, who has since left Charleston, says that even with the communications barrier, the universal language was the engineering plan, cultural adaptation came in time.
The obstacles in Charleston have also presented opportunities for Boeing. The Dreamliner Four center fuselage production incident was used to reduce the traveled work coming to Washington. The repair, which was completed within days of the initial incident, caused Boeing to reassess its delivery of the section.
The center fuselage was initially due in by the end of June, but was delivered five weeks later than initially planned. Rather than deliver as soon as the repair was complete, Boeing opted to hold the section in Charleston to continue work to increase the completion of assembly.
"We will not be efficient in our ramp up if we continue to let the partners travel work," said Shanahan. "This whole production system is based on the model that says we will not travel work.
"When I put work into final assembly, and we've demonstrated this over and over, we are not good and efficient at doing [traveled] work. The supplier, the partner can do it 10 times better than we can. At some point you have to just say, we have to ring this out of the production system."
1. Dreamliners 4-7 at Spirit Aerosystems in Wichita.
2. Dreamliner 5 center fuselage in Charleston.
3. Global Aeronautica body join tooling.
4. Dreamliner 7 aft fuselage at Vought.
5. Aft fuselage for Dreamliners 12, 13 and 14






on August 6, 2008 5:55 PM | Reply
Spirit Aerosystems failed to reach an agreement with any of its major labor unions during mid-contract talks over the past couple months. The IAM refused to even vote on the company's offer and promised a strike in 2011. The IBEW likewise refused to vote the offer. SPEEA voted the offer but its members rejected it by an 80% vote.
Unless something drastic changes at Spirit, just about the time Boeing gets the 787 production line up and running they're going to run out of forward fuselages as Spirit's production facilities grind to a halt in a series of labor actions.
on August 6, 2008 6:21 PM | Reply
I think I may have asked this before, but I cant remember the answer or the post where I asked it...
"The Wichita based-company delivered the nose section for Dreamliner Four 100% complete."
When you say % complete for a section of the a/c, do you mean that there was no traveled work required for integration, or x% complete minus the expected traveled work.
on August 7, 2008 7:45 AM | Reply
Delivered 100% complete means just that... Read back through the blog for the articles when Jon was here (in Wichita). Everything that Spirit was supposed to install was installed, weeks before the unit was shipped.
@ Ray: Don't forget, Boeing IAM negotiations come before Spirit's next round, Boeing themselves could shut down production just fine. No need to go blaming Spirit just quite yet. Boeing's IAM has struck a bit more frequently than SPEEA has (3 times in recent history to 1 time), and IAM in general seems to strike more (Hawker BeechCraft?).