UK and Italy have to choose – Eurofighter or JSF?

It was inevitable, perhaps: the UK and Italy – the only Eurofighter Typhoon partners that also plan to buy the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter – are being forced to choose between the two aircraft, according to a report in The Times.

The Times says the UK Ministry of Defence is trying to find a way out of its committment to buy 88 more Tranche 3 Typhoons, and to reduce, delay or cancel the final order. Italy also wants to cut its Tranche 3 order, the report suggests.

Citing defence sources, The Times says the UK Treasury will not allow the MoD to buy both Tranche 3 Eurofighters and the 150 or so Lockheed Martin F-35Bs it wants. BAE Systems has a piece of both fighter programmes.

My first guess is the JSF will win – the F-35B is the only STOVL option to replace the UK’s Harriers on land and at sea. The Royal Navy’s new CVF carriers could operate conventional fighters, but are being designed around the JSF.

And because of delays in developing the Eurofighter’s multi-role capability, the F-35 will enter service around 2014 with a greater combat potential.

But – and it is a big but – cancelling Tranche 3 Typhoons would leave the UK (and Italy) entirely at the mercy of the US budget process, which is capable of cutting, delaying and even cancelling the JSF programme without consideration of its allies.

F-35sm.jpg Typhoonsm.jpg


2 Responses to UK and Italy have to choose – Eurofighter or JSF?

  1. Wren Mandagorn 14 September, 2007 at 10:04 am #

    Your story actually misses one major point, the MoD (and the RAF in particular) wish to cancel the Tranche 3 purchase of Eurofighter and acquire more JSFs in the form of the US Navy (F-35C) version.

    The RAF and RN view is to purchase 138 F-35B versions to replace the Harrier fleet and 100 C versions – although strangely not for carrier operations, more due to the fact that the US Navy version has the longest range of the 3 variants.

  2. The Woracle 14 September, 2007 at 2:58 pm #

    Interesting. I have always wondered why Australia is not interested in the F-35C variant, because of its extra range. I would think a combined fleet of Cs and STOVL Bs would make a powerful and flexible force. But the F-35C is the most expensive variant.

Leave a Reply