Air France-KLM, Alitalia and Lufthansa are under investigation for potential price-fixing on Japan routes

Airlines have once again found themselves at the centre of a cartel investigation, with European Commission officials having raided the offices of Air France-KLM, Alitalia and Lufthansa on 11 March. The EC carried out "unannounced inspections" on the premises of what it said at the time were international passenger carriers that provide services on long-haul routes between Europe and a third country.

Lufthansa has since issued a statement admitting that it is one of those carriers and that the investigation is focused on "anti-competitive price-fixing and collusive behaviour in traffic between the European Union and Japan". Air France-KLM and Alitalia have also admitted that they are being investigated. The carriers all say they are co-operating fully with the probe. Lufthansa chief executive Wolfgang Mayrhuber says the German ­carrier "wouldn't tolerate any ­irregularities", and the probe "does not mean that any ­irregularities have taken place".

Mike Pullen, head of EU/competition law at DLA Piper, says cartel investigations require "lots of resources and lots of planning" and are carried out either when there is a "reasonable suspicion" or a whistle blower. "I find it ­surprising that major airlines with large legal departments are finding themselves in this ­position," says Pullen.

These raids are the latest in a string of probes targeting the airline industry. Two years ago airline offices around the world were raided as part of a cargo price-fixing investigation. Criminal proceedings are still ongoing and as leniency applications come in, it could be that information relating to other cartel ­activity is now coming to light.

Lufthansa offices    
Lufthansa's offices were raided by European Commission officials

 

TIMELINE

February 2006

US DoJ and the EC begin probes into suspected price-fixing by air cargo carriers

August 2006

Lufthansa offers $85 million to settle class action claims relating to US cargo price-fixing and is accepted into DoJ's leniency programme

September 2007

BA fined $200 million and Korean Air fined $100 million by the DoJ

November 2007

DoJ fines Qantas $61 million

December 2007

EC accuses several carriers of cargo price-fixing activity

March 2008

EC raids offices of Air France-KLM, Alitalia and Lufthansa in fresh cartel probe

 




 

Source: Airline Business